Error reduction rate per redundant module for the second. Triple modular redundancy tmr is a suitable fault tolerant technique for srambased fpga. Tripletriple redundant reliable onboard computer based on. Triple modular redundancy tmr is a classical approach for achieving fault tolerance in missioncritical systems 27. Parallel processing along with triple modular redundancy tmr has been used to increase the operating speed of the system and also to make the system fault. Triple modular redundancy, a proper noun, is a based on proven statistics and stringent mathematics. One of the primary mitigation techniques is called triple modular redundancy tmr. For fpga systems that employ configuration scrubbing, majority voters are needed in all feedback paths to ensure proper synchronization between the tmr replicates. Triple modular redundancy, tmr is a faulttolerant structure of n modular redundancy, in which three systems execute a process and that consequence is processed by a voting system to create a. Use voting to elect majority result and isolate atfault cpu. Voter circuits, redundant voters, imperfect voters, and comparisons with parallel and standby schemes are included.
The 2300t hics high integrity control system ensures the highest integrity and the highest availability of user data. In this paper, we develop the avtmr all voting triple modular redundancy system that is operated correctly in the case of a fault, and evaluate the avtmr system in the failure rate based on. Reduced triple modular redundancy for tolerating seus in sram. The hardened design has 200% more area than the original circuit. Quadruple modular redundant technology for safety systems. This unique qmr technology, based on a high level of selftesting and diagnostics, has proven that qmr is the best. Triple modular redundancy layerzero power systems, inc. In the case of the lifetime is represented by the random variable t t of three same components in tmr system have the same distribution which is the exponential distribution with the same shape parameter.
The design and evaluation of all voting triple modular. Pdf on the optimal design of triple modular redundancy logic for srambased fpgas divya k and fernanda kastensmidt academia. There are similar sounding terms like, tri or triple redundant, used in industry to describe other sts products but they simply do not yield the same, high level of reliability. Pdf hierarchical triplemodular redundancy htmr network. Triple modular redundancy using intel advanced vector. A typical example is a complex computer system which has. A new scheme for implementing highly reliable digital systems is proposed. Triple modular redundancy, tmr is a faulttolerant structure of nmodular redundancy, in which three systems execute a process and that consequence is processed by a voting system to create a. Tmr defend the fpga circuit by creating three copies of a circuit. Triple modular redundancy verification via heuristic. The commonly used techniques for controlling and isolating faults in the system are replication and check pointing. Reliability analysis of triple modular redundancy system.
Tmr detects faults by simple comparison of three replicas and. The gpscompass pro modules in the a3 pro upgrade kit are the same as the a3s. User manual make sure all of the parts listed in the in the box document are included in the package. Chapter 4 studies the reliability and availability gains obtained for n. Pdf layout design and simulation of fault tolerant triple modular. Triple modular redundancy system with exponential distribution. Triple modular redundancy tmr is a wellknown mitigation technique, which provides a full masking capability to single faults, although at a great cost in terms of area and power consumption. Triple modular redundancy verification via heuristic netlist. Triple modular redundancy tmr is a common technique to protect memory elements for digital processing systems subject to radiation effects such as in space, highaltitude, or near nuclear sources. Tmr detects faults by simple comparison of three replicas and performs fault recovery by majority voting, i.
Find out information about tripple modular redundancy. Estimation the failure rate and reliability of the triple. This study aimed to create mathematical model to find the optimum values of the distribution parameters of the triple modular redundant system. Keyword fault masking, fault tolerant design, triplemodular redundancy tmr. In this paper, a simple probabilistic model was proposed for analysis of fault masking performance of hierarchical tmr networks.
The outcome of tmrapproximate tmr modules serves as the voter input to produce the final output of a system. Comparative redundancy, an alternative to triple modular. Triple modular redundancy tmr is a common reliability technique for mitigating single event upsets seus in fpga designs operating in radiation environments. Triple modular redundancy tmr you can implement tmr technique on critical logic such as state machines. The system must be able to maintain its performance in carrying out. Mar 05, 2019 triple modular redundancy triple modular redundancy tmr uses three functionally equivalent units to provide redundant backup. Ceng 5334 chapter 4 nmodular redundancy page 3 of 15. The ibm journal said the concept is something like a figure where there are three boxes labeled m. The approach is called functional triple modular redundancy ftmr. Because the working principle of approximate tmr conditionally allows one of the approximate modules to differ from the original circuit, it. Triple modular redundancy triple modular redundancy tmr uses three functionally equivalent units to provide redundant backup. The a3 pros three gps units and imus add triple modular redundancy to greatly reduce the risk of system failure. Reliability analysis of triple modular redundancy system with spare i khalid a.
Use of approximate triple modular redundancy for fault. In computing, triple modular redundancy, sometimes called triplemode redundancy, tmr is a. The use of triplemodular redundancy to improve computer. A microblaze tmr subsystem is of fault tolerant fail safe ftfs type, which means that it continues to work without degradation after the first failure ft and will detect a second failure fs. In computing, triple modular redundancy, sometimes called triple mode redundancy, tmr is a faulttolerant form of n modular redundancy, in which three systems perform a process and that result is processed by a majorityvoting system to produce a single output.
When sharing io, the controllers from the mark vie and mark vies can read inputs from all io modules, but write outputs only to their own io modules. Triple modular redundancy when designing the configuration for space flight, the designer must think about mitigation techniques for radiation effects. For that reason, partial redundancy is often applied instead to alleviate these overheads. Contribute to thalesriscvtmr development by creating an account on github. The use of triplemodular redundancy to improve computer reliability abstract. A fault tolerant voter for approximate triple modular. Quadruple modular redundant technology for safety systems honeywells quadruple modular redundant qmr technology with award winning 2oo4d architecture sets the standard for how safety instrumented systems should be designed. Contribute to thalesgrouptmr development by creating an account on github. A vhdl approach has been developed for automatic tmr insertion and a demonstration design has been developed. Tripple modular redundancy article about tripple modular. Design and implementation of triple modular redundant tmr.
When the second failure occurs, the voter can no longer work without a majority. Verification of triple modular redundancy tmr insertion for. In reliability engineering, dual modular redundancy dmr is when components of a system are duplicated, providing redundancy in case one should fail. However, tmr suffers from a 200% area overhead problem 10,11.
The first part, section 2 presents n modular redundancy. One of the proposed techniques for meeting the severe reliability requirements inherent in certain future computer applications is described. Tmr is one of the most general and effective hardening techniques. If any one of the three system fails, the other two systems can correct. Berg at radiation effects on components and systems radecs conference, bremen, germany, september 1923, 2016. In engineering, redundancy is the duplication of critical components or functions of a system with the intention of increasing reliability and decreasing the failure rate of the system, usually in the case of failsafe. Triple modular redundancy triple modular redundancy tmr is a classical approach for achieving fault tolerance in missioncritical systems 27. Redundancy is a technique to improve the reliability and availability of a system.
A form of redundancy in which the original computer unit is triplicated and each of the three independent units feeds into a majority voter, which outputs. Distributed tmr dtmr or global tmr gtmr xtmr but its not this easy tmr schemes are differentiated by how the triplication is performed and where the voters are placed. Triple modular redundancy, sometimes called triplemode redundancy, tmr is a faulttolerant form of nmodular redundancy, in which three systems perform a process and that result is processed by a majorityvoting system to produce a single output. If any one of the three systems fails, the other two systems can correct and mask the fault. Sonza reorda2 1universidade estadual do rio grande do sul uergs engenharia em sistemas digitais. Design and implementation of triple modular redundant.
This paper presents an approach to verify the correct implementation of tmr for the memory elements of a given netlist i. The method has a circuitry overhead which is comparable to that of the triple modular redundancy tmr scheme, although it is shown to have a reliability, and more importantly a mean time to failure, improvement well beyond that expected from the standard tmr systems. This approach is very common in aerospace applications where the cost of failure is extremely high. Triple modular redundancy tmr you can implement tmr.
March 18, 2004for missioncritical processes and applications, theres no substitute for triple modular redundancy tmr. Originally, tmr was used on the module level and for protecting sequential. Aikofahi hereby grant permission to the wallace memorial library of the rochester institute of technologyto reproduce mythesis in whole or in part. Fault tolerance is a high performance system and they have ability of system to continue errorfree operation in presence of unexpected fault. Verification of triple modular redundancy tmr insertion. The method is often referred to as triple modular redundancy tmr. The imu pro module includes an imu with a builtin barometer.
Tmr is more reliable than dmr due to two main aspects. If any one of the three systems fails, the other two systems can correct and mask. Reduced triple modular redundancy for tolerating seus in. This document discusses the use of triple modular redundancy tmr for the protection of combinatorial and sequential logic in reprogrammable logic devices. Performance improvements obtained by second order tmr network were theoretically compared with first order tmr network. Triple module redundancy design techniques for virtex fpgas xapp197 v1. Intel stratix 10 seu mitigation user guide archives on page 31. Tmr guarantees an accurate output through a majority voter, even when a single module is faulty. Triple modular redundancy io modules on a common ionet to simplify operations and maintenance. The timing simulation shows that time requires for fault detection and repair is in 8ns and it is very low. Transfer function of triple modular redundancy fault.
Pdf on the optimal design of triple modular redundancy. Verification of triple modular redundancy tmr insertion for reliable and trusted systems melanie berg1, kenneth label2. Triple modular redundancy tmr uses three functionally equivalent units to provide redundant backup. However, one of the main challenges in achieving 100%. The use of triple modular redundancy to improve computer reliability abstract. It is a form of nmodular redundancy in which three systems perform a process and that result is processed by a majority voting system to produce a single output. It is particularly applied to systems where the duplicated components work in parallel, particularly in faulttolerant computer systems.
Pdf a fault tolerant voter circuit for triple modular redundant. However, one of the main challenges in achieving 100% robustness in designs protected by tmr running on programmable platforms is to prevent upsets in the routing from provoking undesirable connections between signals from. Regardless of how many clock stages may, or may not, lie between the inputs and outputs of the adder, the output is always a function of the inputs only. On the optimal design of triple modular redundancy logic for srambased fpgas f.
Hierarchical application of triple modular redundancy tmr increases fault tolerance of digital integrated circuit ic. Hierarchical application of triplemodular redundancy tmr increases fault tolerance of digital integrated circuit ic. Localized triple modular redundancy ltmr redundant data path. In the proposed architecture, an onboard computer is designed based on triple modular redundancy tmr. This paper aims to provide control over the detected fault by using the antique technique of triple modular redundancy tmr which is a. In this context, approximate tmr, which is the implementation. Introduction one of the most important elements in the design of embedded systems on the satellite system is hardware fault tolerance. Approximate triple modular redundancy has been proposed in the literature to overcome the area overhead issue of triple modular redundancy tmr. Matrix multiplication on gpus with online fault tolerance.
A fault tolerant voter for approximate triple modular redundancy. Verification of triple modular redundancy tmr ntrs nasa. Voter insertion algorithms for fpga designs using triple. It significantly presents the formulation of transfer function, in its simplest form, of a triple modular redundancy faulttolerant sensor system. Triple modular redundancy tmr protection against single event upsets seus 10 deliverable to nasa electronic parts and packaging nepp program to be published on nepp. Design and implementation of triple modular redundant tmr system on linuxbased onboard computer for cubesat dr. A computer system of the standby redundancy type including three active logic modules and at least one spare module, characterized by the provision of triple modular redundancy means for correcting and locating the failure of a first one of said active logic modules, in combination with sparing means for reconfiguring the system to bypass the faulty module and to substitute the spare module. Hierarchical triplemodular redundancy htmr network.
It is a form of n modular redundancy in which three systems perform a process and that result is processed by a majority voting system to produce a single output. With just one failure, tmr continues to operate while continuously voting out the one failed module. Pdf on jan 1, 2017, mohammed hadifur rahman and others published a fault tolerant voter circuit for triple modular redundant system find, read and. Modular redundancy reliability of computer systems and.
On the optimal design of triple modular redundancy logic. Triple modular redundant configuration as it can be seen in figure 2, the redundancy of the onboard computer is in componentlevel and all. Rtp has created a new tmr architecture designed specifically for process control. Triple modular redundancy, sometimes called triple mode redundancy, tmr is a faulttolerant form of n modular redundancy, in which three systems perform a process and that result is processed by a majorityvoting system to produce a single output. Triple modular redundancy tmr triple modular redundancy tmr is a classical hardware redundancy technique for fault tolerance. However, one of the main challenges in achieving 100% robustness in designs protected by tmr running on programmable platforms is to prevent upsets in the. On the optimal design of triple modular redundancy logic for. Fault tolerant and correction system using triple modular. Because the working principle of approximate tmr conditionally allows one of the approximate modules to differ from the original. Triple modular redundancy using fault tolerant technique. Redundant system basic concepts national instruments. A technique known as selective triple modular redundancy stmr is proposed in 12 that employs partial redundancy to introduce seu immunity.
The effects of race conditions when implementing single. Transfer function of triple modular redundancy faulttolerant. Triple modular redundancy tmr is a suitable fault tolerant technique for sram based fpga. Any reproduction will not be for commercial use or profit. Pdf design and analysis of a fault tolerant microprocessor. Intel stratix 10 seu mitigation user guide archives on page 31 provides a list of user guides for previous versions of the advanced seu.
865 783 114 925 977 275 878 291 288 363 118 1353 1366 162 461 1385 1121 1104 230 1025 656 67 1289 415 763 35 1147 1013 983 1340 1078 88 617 1123 963 553 513 438 1217 726 737 424 321 317 574